FAQs

Q: Why are independent directors required in CMBS transactions?

In CMBS transactions, independent directors are often required to help maintain separateness between the borrower and its affiliates. Their presence reduces the risk of strategic bankruptcy filings and supports the bankruptcy-remote structure expected by lenders and rating agencies.

Q: What is a bankruptcy-remote entity in commercial real estate?

A: A bankruptcy-remote entity is a legal structure designed to reduce the risk that a property-owning entity will voluntarily file for bankruptcy. This is achieved through limited-purpose provisions, separateness covenants, and governance safeguards such as appointing an independent director or manager.

Q: Is a bankruptcy-remote entity "bankruptcy-proof"?

A: No. No structure can permanently take away an entity's legal right to seek bankruptcy protection, and provisions that try to waive that right outright are widely regarded as unenforceable. Bankruptcy remoteness makes a voluntary filing harder and keeps the entity separate from an affiliate's bankruptcy. It raises the barrier to a filing but does not eliminate it.

Q: What is the difference between an SPE, an SPV, and a BRE?

A: SPE (special purpose entity) is the standard term in U.S. commercial real estate finance. SPV (special purpose vehicle) is more common in securitization and cross-border structured finance. BRE (bankruptcy-remote entity) describes a characteristic rather than an entity type: it is an SPE or SPV that carries the full set of bankruptcy-remote features. An entity can be single-purpose without being bankruptcy remote, so read what the term sheet actually requires rather than relying on the label. The specific requirements still depend on the entity type and the transaction.

Q: Is forming a single-asset LLC enough to meet a lender's SPE requirement?

A: Usually not. Lenders typically expect a limited purpose, a restriction on additional debt, separateness covenants, an independent director or independent manager, a springing member for single-member LLCs and, on larger or securitized loans, a non-consolidation opinion. Borrowers who form a plain single-asset LLC and assume the requirement is satisfied are often surprised late in the closing process.

Q: What are separateness covenants?

A: Separateness covenants are ongoing operating rules that keep the SPE distinct from its sponsor and affiliates. Common examples are keeping separate books, accounts and financial statements; not commingling funds; using the entity's own name on invoices, checks and bank accounts; dealing with affiliates on arm's-length terms; not guaranteeing anyone else's debts; and observing organizational formalities. CMBS loan documents often contain around twenty of them. Inadvertent breaches are common, usually because several properties share the same bookkeeping.

Q: Who is responsible for complying with the SPE’s separateness covenants?

A: The borrower, its managers, and its ownership are responsible for ongoing compliance. The independent director is not responsible for monitoring routine operations unless a separate written engagement expressly provides otherwise.

Q: What records should an SPE keep to support its bankruptcy-remote status?

A: Keep separate books and records, meeting minutes, written consents, documentation of material decisions, and up-to-date organizational records. In a period of financial distress, creditors look at whether affiliated entities actually stayed separate, and records kept long before the crisis become the evidence.

Q: How long do SPE requirements stay in effect?

A: For the life of the loan. Compliance generally runs until the earliest of loan payoff, assignment of the note and mortgage in a refinancing, or assumption of the loan by a new borrower. Breaches made during the term often come to light later, at refinancing or in a workout.

Q: Why are most SPEs formed in Delaware?

A: Delaware offers extensive case law, a long-established corporate framework and predictable outcomes in complex financial transactions. Texas recently passed legislation allowing broader elimination of fiduciary duties in LLCs, which has prompted some discussion. However, there is uncertainty about how Texas courts will interpret it, so Delaware remains the dominant choice for institutional structured finance.

Q: How did the General Growth Properties bankruptcy change SPE governance?

A: In 2009, General Growth Properties filed for bankruptcy along with hundreds of property-level SPE subsidiaries. Creditors argued that many of those SPEs were solvent and separate, but the court allowed the filings to proceed. Lenders and counsel responded with narrower fiduciary duties for independent managers, stronger separateness covenants, limits on removing independent directors, and a requirement that independent directors come from nationally recognized service providers. Many of these provisions are now standard.

Q: What does an independent director do in commercial real estate transactions?

A: An independent director serves as an objective decision-maker for a special purpose entity (SPE) used in structured finance or commercial real estate transactions. Their role is typically limited to reviewing and approving major actions such as voluntary bankruptcy filings or significant structural changes, helping preserve the entity’s bankruptcy-remote status.

Q: What is the difference between an independent director and a board director?

A: A traditional board director participates in company strategy and ongoing management oversight. An independent director in a structured finance SPE has a much narrower role focused on protecting bankruptcy remoteness and reviewing specific major decisions.

Q: What is an independent manager in a Delaware LLC?

A: An independent manager is a third party appointed to a Delaware limited liability company (LLC), usually one formed as a special purpose entity. The independent manager is required to approve certain material actions, particularly those involving bankruptcy or dissolution, to protect lender and investor interests.

Q: Does it matter whether the documents say "independent director" or "independent manager"?

A: Yes. A corporation has an independent director, a limited liability company has an independent manager, and a statutory trust has an independent trustee. Because most CMBS borrowers are Delaware LLCs, "independent manager" is usually the correct term. Mixed usage within one set of documents suggests the provisions were copied from a template without a close read, and it can cause friction at closing.

Q: What are "material actions" in a bankruptcy-remote SPE?

A: Material actions generally include voluntary bankruptcy filings, mergers, consolidations, dissolution, amendments to governing documents, or significant asset transfers. These actions usually require approval from an independent director or manager.

Q: Will an independent director take control of my property or business?

A: No. An independent director does not approve leases, sign construction draws, hire property managers, set budgets or take part in operations. Their consent is required only for a short list of material actions set out in the organizational documents, such as a bankruptcy filing. Day-to-day control of the asset stays with the sponsor.

Q: How does an independent director protect lenders and investors?

A: Independent directors help ensure that major decisions affecting the entity, especially bankruptcy filings, are evaluated independently and not driven solely by sponsor interests. This governance safeguard supports lender collateral protection and investor confidence.

Q: Does an independent director represent the lender?

A: No. An independent director is not the lender’s representative or agent. Although the appointment supports the lender’s bankruptcy-remoteness requirements, the director must exercise independent judgment and fulfill the duties established by the entity’s governing documents and applicable law.

Q: Whose interests does an independent director consider when voting on a bankruptcy filing?

A: The SPE's. The decision is evaluated from the perspective of the entity itself, consistent with its governing documents. The sponsor's financial condition is relevant context, but it does not replace the director's obligations to the entity they serve.

Q: Do all commercial real estate deals require an independent director?

A: No. Independent directors are most common in securitized, institutional, or structured credit transactions where bankruptcy remoteness is critical. Smaller balance or portfolio loans may not require this governance structure.

Q: When is an independent director required for a real estate loan?

A: Independent directors are typically required in securitized, institutional, or structured finance transactions, including CMBS, SASB, private credit, mezzanine financing, and certain project finance deals. Loan documents often mandate their appointment as a condition of closing.

Q: Why are independent directors required in CMBS transactions?

A: In CMBS (Commercial Mortgage-Backed Securities) transactions, independent directors are often required to help maintain separateness between the borrower and its affiliates. Their presence reduces the risk of strategic bankruptcy filings and supports the bankruptcy-remote structure expected by lenders and rating agencies.

Q: At what loan size do lenders require an independent director?

A: It varies by lender and deal. According to CREFC, rating agencies historically required an independent party on CMBS borrowers with loans above roughly $20 million. Practitioner guidance suggests lenders may waive the requirement on loans below about $15 million and may require two independents at or above about $50 million. These figures are typical, not fixed.

Q: Can a borrower negotiate out of the independent director requirement?

A: Rarely on a CMBS loan, because the requirement comes from the securitization and rating agency criteria rather than from the individual lender. CRE CLO lenders and debt funds apply similar requirements because their exit depends on the loan being eligible for the CLO. Banks have the most discretion, but many follow market convention so they can sell or securitize the loan later. The pricing a borrower is quoted often already assumes the structure is in place.

Q: Do mezzanine lenders require independent directors too?

A: Often, yes. Mezzanine lenders frequently require independent governance at the mezzanine borrower as well, so the structure has independent directors or managers at more than one tier.

Q: How do rating agencies evaluate independent directors?

A: In rated transactions the independent director feeds into the rating. Agencies look at whether the person is genuinely independent, whether a firm with insurance and continuity planning stands behind them, whether the consent right is actually enforceable (including "no removal without replacement"), whether the governance matches the non-consolidation opinion's assumptions, and the provider's track record. Choosing a provider is a diligence item, not a commodity purchase.

Q: Are independent directors only used in commercial real estate?

A: No. The same structure appears wherever lenders or investors underwrite specific assets rather than the operating company behind them. Examples include infrastructure and project finance, asset-backed securitizations, aviation and airport financings, solar and renewable energy projects, receivables and trade finance, fund finance and NAV facilities, and data center and digital infrastructure securitizations. SPE Specialists serves transactions across all of these.

Q: How do independent director requirements differ outside commercial real estate?

A: The role itself is the same. Three things differ. Who reviews the appointment: in ABS and project bonds, rating agency criteria tend to drive the requirement more directly. How many seats: larger programs may need independents at several tiers, such as the depositor, issuer and transferor, or the project company, holdco and aggregator. How long the appointment lasts: infrastructure, airport concessions and master trusts can run for decades, which makes keeping the appointment current especially important.

Q: What qualifications must an independent director meet?

A: Independent directors must be unaffiliated with the borrower and free from material financial or operational ties that could compromise objectivity. Independence standards are typically defined in loan documents and required by lenders or rating agencies.

Q: What is the five-year non-affiliation standard?

A: Many transaction documents require that an independent director or manager have no prohibited employment, ownership, family, business, or financial relationship with the borrower and its affiliates during the preceding five years. The exact definition varies by transaction.

Q: Can an employee or affiliate of the borrower serve as the independent director?

A: No. Loan documents and organizational documents typically prohibit employees, owners, affiliates, family members, and other interested parties with material relationships to the borrower from serving in the role.

Q: Can a friend, attorney, or accountant of the sponsor serve as independent director?

A: No. Existing professional, financial, or personal relationships generally violate the transaction’s independence requirements. The governing documents must be reviewed before determining whether any candidate qualifies.

Q: How is an independent director’s eligibility confirmed?

A: Eligibility is evaluated against the definitions and restrictions contained in the loan and organizational documents, including relationships with the borrower, sponsor, lender, owners, property manager, and affiliates.

Q: What is a nationally recognized independent director provider?

A: Some loan and organizational documents require the director to be supplied by a nationally recognized company that routinely provides independent governance services, helping ensure experience, independence, continuity, and institutional support.

Q: Can the same independent director serve multiple SPEs?

A: Yes. Provided the individual satisfies the independence requirements for each entity and no conflict of interest exists. Portfolio and multi-property transactions frequently use the same qualified professional across multiple related SPEs.

Q: What should I look for in an independent director provider?

A: Look for responsiveness when a closing schedule tightens, acceptance by rating agencies in rated transactions, a firm with succession planning and insurance behind the individual, genuine independence, transparent pricing, and a provider who actually reviews the documents instead of only signing a signature page.

Q: How far ahead of closing should we engage an independent director provider?

A: Identify the requirement at the term sheet stage and engage a provider 30 or more days before closing. Aim to finalize the independence and material-action provisions two to three weeks before closing. Appointment involves conflict clearance, document review, a consistency check against the non-consolidation opinion, and delivery of consents and certificates, and any of these steps can turn up an issue. When a schedule is compressed, SPE Specialists can execute the same day with electronic signatures.

Q: What documents are needed to appoint an independent director?

A: The required materials commonly include the term sheet, draft operating agreement, certificate of formation, engagement agreement, and lender certificate. The engagement agreement and lender certificate are drafted by SPE Specialists.

Q: Who signs the independent director engagement agreement?

A: The engagement agreement is generally signed by the entity and the service provider. The appointment itself is documented by written consent, resolution, joinder, or another document depending on the entity’s organizational structure and operating agreement.

Q: Does SPE Specialists need to take any action at closing?

A: Usually not. SPE Specialists completes its review and signs its signature page well before closing, so there is often nothing left for us to do on the closing day.

Q: Can an independent director be appointed after a loan has already closed?

A: Yes. Although appointments should ordinarily occur before or at closing when required, post-closing appointments may be needed to correct an omission, replace a departing director, amend the borrower’s structure, address a loan modification, or satisfy a new lender requirement.

Q: Can an independent director resign or be removed?

A: Yes, but resignation and removal are usually subject to notice, replacement, and eligibility requirements. The borrower generally cannot leave the position vacant or appoint an unqualified replacement.

Q: What happens if our independent director provider merges, exits the business, or the named individual stops serving?

A: An appointment does not maintain itself. If the seat is no longer validly filled, the gap usually comes to light at the worst moment: a refinancing, an assumption, a workout or a distress event. Well-drafted documents bar actions that need the independent's consent while the seat is vacant, and they require a replacement before a removal takes effect. Confirm that the appointment is current before any major transaction. SPE Specialists can help verify an existing appointment or serve as the replacement.

Q: What happens to the independent director after the loan is repaid?

A: After the loan is repaid and the applicable requirements are released, the borrower may terminate the engagement and remove the independent director in accordance with the organizational documents.

Q: What is a non-consolidation opinion?

A: A non-consolidation opinion is a legal opinion addressing the likelihood that an SPE would remain separate from specified affiliates if one entered bankruptcy. It must be provided by qualified legal counsel.

Q: Can SPE Specialists provide a non-consolidation opinion?

A: No. A non-consolidation opinion is a legal opinion that must be provided by qualified counsel. SPE Specialists can provide the independent governance personnel required by the organizational structure supporting that opinion.

Q: Can a non-consolidation opinion be required again after closing?

A: Yes. A guarantor substitution, hiring a borrower-affiliated replacement property manager, or certain equity transfers can each trigger a new opinion requirement. Counsel may also be unable to deliver an opinion if the entity has commingled funds, shared bank accounts with an affiliate, or lacked independent governance. Sponsors planning an internal restructuring during the loan term should check this early.

Q: Can I use my existing entity for a CMBS loan, or do I need a new one?

A: CMBS lenders prefer a newly formed entity with no operating history. An existing ("recycled") entity can sometimes be used, but it generally has to certify that it has always operated as though the SPE requirements were in place since formation. If it can't, the property may have to be transferred into a new entity, which can trigger transfer taxes, property tax reassessment and permit or license reissuance. Settle this question before signing the term sheet.

Q: What is a springing member?

A: A springing member, sometimes called a special member, is appointed to help preserve the continued existence of an LLC if it would otherwise have no remaining member. The role is generally passive unless a specified event occurs.

Q: Is a springing member the same as an independent manager?

A: No. An independent manager reviews and votes on specified Material Actions. A springing member has the narrower function of becoming a member only when necessary to prevent the LLC from dissolving because it no longer has a member.

Q: Does a springing member own an economic interest in the SPE?

A: No. A properly structured springing or special member typically has no right to profits, losses, distributions, or the underlying property. Its rights are limited to those provided in the operating agreement.

Q: Does a springing member take over the borrower’s operations?

A: No. A springing member does not ordinarily assume day-to-day management authority, control the property, or receive an economic interest. Its role is limited by the operating agreement.

Q: Can the same person serve as both independent manager and springing member?

A: Yes. Provided the individual meets the governing document, lender, and legal requirements. The roles remain legally distinct even when held by one qualified individual.

FAQs

Q: What is a bankruptcy-remote entity in commercial real estate?

Q: Is a bankruptcy-remote entity "bankruptcy-proof"?

Q: What is the difference between an SPE, an SPV, and a BRE?

Q: Is forming a single-asset LLC enough to meet a lender's SPE requirement?

Q: What are separateness covenants?

Q: Who is responsible for complying with the SPE’s separateness covenants?

Q: What records should an SPE keep to support its bankruptcy-remote status?

Q: How long do SPE requirements stay in effect?

Q: Why are most SPEs formed in Delaware?

Q: How did the General Growth Properties bankruptcy change SPE governance?

Q: What does an independent director do in commercial real estate transactions?

Q: What is the difference between an independent director and a board director?

Q: What is an independent manager in a Delaware LLC?

Q: Does it matter whether the documents say "independent director" or "independent manager"?

Q: What are "material actions" in a bankruptcy-remote SPE?

Q: Will an independent director take control of my property or business?

​

Q: How does an independent director protect lenders and investors?

Q: Does an independent director represent the lender?

Q: Whose interests does an independent director consider when voting on a bankruptcy filing?

Q: Do all commercial real estate deals require an independent director?

​

Q: When is an independent director required for a real estate loan?

Q: Why are independent directors required in CMBS transactions?

Q: At what loan size do lenders require an independent director?

​

Q: Can a borrower negotiate out of the independent director requirement?

Q: Do mezzanine lenders require independent directors too?

Q: How do rating agencies evaluate independent directors?

Q: Are independent directors only used in commercial real estate?

Q: How do independent director requirements differ outside commercial real estate?

​

Q: What qualifications must an independent director meet?

​

Q: What is the five-year non-affiliation standard?

Q: Can an employee or affiliate of the borrower serve as the independent director?

Q: Can a friend, attorney, or accountant of the sponsor serve as independent director?

Q: How is an independent director’s eligibility confirmed?

Q: What is a nationally recognized independent director provider?

Q: Can the same independent director serve multiple SPEs?

Q: What should I look for in an independent director provider?

Q: How far ahead of closing should we engage an independent director provider?

Q: What documents are needed to appoint an independent director?

Q: Who signs the independent director engagement agreement?

Q: Does SPE Specialists need to take any action at closing?

Q: Can an independent director be appointed after a loan has already closed?

Q: Can an independent director resign or be removed?

Q: What happens if our independent director provider merges, exits the business, or the named individual stops serving?

Q: What happens to the independent director after the loan is repaid?

Q: What is a non-consolidation opinion?

Q: Can SPE Specialists provide a non-consolidation opinion?

Q: Can a non-consolidation opinion be required again after closing?

Q: Can I use my existing entity for a CMBS loan, or do I need a new one?

Q: What is a springing member?

Q: Is a springing member the same as an independent manager?

Q: Does a springing member own an economic interest in the SPE?

Q: Does a springing member take over the borrower’s operations?

Q: Can the same person serve as both independent manager and springing member?