What Is CMBS Defeasance?


Defeasance is the process of a fixed-rate CMBS loan gets its property released from the mortgage instead of a traditional prepayment penalty. The borrower doesn't pay the loan off but instead, it buys a portfolio of U.S. government securities whose principal and interest payments exactly matches the loan's remaining scheduled payments. Those securities are pledged to the lender in place of the property, the property lien is released, and the loan keeps paying on its original schedule until maturity. The cashflow remains for the bond holders but the property level risk is replaced with AAA credit.
Key Takeaways
Defeasance is a collateral substitution, not a prepayment. The note stays outstanding and the bondholders keep receiving the payments they expected.
The replacement collateral is a portfolio of U.S. Treasury securities, or Treasury and agency securities where the loan documents permit them, sized so its cash flows cover every remaining loan payment.
The process typically runs 30 to 45 days and closes at the same time as the property sale or refinancing.
Because the original borrower is selling or refinancing the property and leaving the loan, a new entity, the successor borrower, assumes the loan and holds the securities for the rest of the term.
Why CMBS Loans Can't Simply Be Prepaid
A conduit lender that makes a CMBS loan doesn't hold it. The loan is pooled with others into a trust, and the trust issues bonds to investors. Those investors bought a predictable stream of fixed payments, and the bonds are priced on the assumption that the stream continues to maturity. If a borrower repaid early when rates had fallen, investors would get their principal back at a time when reinvesting it would earn less.
The trust structure adds a tax constraint. CMBS trusts are almost always structured as real estate mortgage investment conduits, or REMICs, which pass income to investors without tax at the trust level. REMIC status depends on the trust holding qualified mortgages and not trading in and out of its assets. Federal tax regulations allow a mortgage's real property collateral to be released and replaced with government securities, and that's exactly what defeasance does, but only after a waiting period.
That waiting period is the defeasance lockout. It commonly ends at the earlier of two years after the loan is securitized or a set period after the loan closes, often three or four years. Until then, neither prepayment nor defeasance is available. After it ends, the loan documents usually allow defeasance until a short open period near maturity, when the loan can be prepaid at par.
Defeasance vs. Yield Maintenance
Some commercial loans have prepayments with yield maintenance: the borrower pays the balance plus a premium that compensates the lender for lost interest, and the note is cancelled. Defeasance reaches a similar economic result in a different way. The borrower doesn't pay the lender a premium but replaced the collateral with US Treasury securities, and when Treasury yields are below the loan's interest rate, it takes more than the outstanding balance to buy a portfolio that produces the same payments. That difference is the main cost of a defeasance.
| Yield maintenance | Defeasance |
What happens to the note | Paid off and cancelled | Stays outstanding to maturity or the open date |
What the lender receives | Cash: balance plus premium | A pledged portfolio of government securities |
Borrower that remains on the loan | None | A successor borrower |
Typical use | Balance-sheet and agency loans | Fixed-rate CMBS loans |
How the Replacement Collateral Works
The securities are bought to match the loan's remaining payment schedule. A securities broker or defeasance consultant builds a laddered portfolio in which bonds mature, or pay coupons, just before each scheduled loan payment date, including the final balloon payment.
An independent accountant reviews the portfolio and issues a verification report certifying that its cash flows are sufficient to make every remaining payment. At closing the securities are delivered to a securities intermediary, usually a bank custodian, and held in a restricted account pledged to the lender. As the securities pay, the intermediary sends the cash to the loan servicer, which applies it to the loan.
Who Is Involved
A defeasance has more parties than most borrowers expect:
Borrower and borrower's counsel. The borrower starts the process and funds it, usually from the proceeds of the sale or refinancing.
Loan servicer and servicer's counsel. The servicer receives the notice and deposit, and its counsel issues the closing checklist and prepares most of the transaction documents.
Defeasance consultant. Coordinates the process, estimates cost, and manages the parties and timeline.
Securities broker. Builds and buys the securities portfolio.
Independent accountant. Issues the verification report.
Securities intermediary or custodian. Holds the securities and remits the cash flows.
Successor borrower. Assumes the loan after the property is released and replaces the original borrower.
Rating agencies, if the loan documents require a rating agency confirmation for the defeasance.
Title company and the buyer's or new lender's team, because the defeasance closes alongside the property transaction.
What Defeasance Costs
The largest cost is the securities portfolio. The lower Treasury yields are relative to the loan's interest rate, and the longer the remaining term, the more the portfolio costs above the outstanding balance. When Treasury yields are above the loan rate, the portfolio can cost less than the balance.
Third-party fees are much smaller than the cost of the securities but still add up: servicer and servicer's counsel fees, consultant, accountant, custodian, borrower's counsel, successor borrower fees, and rating agency fees where they apply.
Where the Successor Borrower Comes In
Defeasance releases the property, but the loan still needs a borrower. The original borrower is selling the property or refinancing it with a new lender, and it doesn't want a loan it no longer benefits from on its books. So at closing, a separate entity assumes the note and holds the pledged securities until the loan is paid at maturity or the open date. That entity is the successor borrower, and it's the subject of Part 2.
The successor borrower is a special purpose entity whose only asset is the defeasance collateral, so the reasoning behind bankruptcy-remote structures applies here too. SPE Specialists covers that reasoning in What Is Bankruptcy Remoteness and Why Does It Matter?.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can every CMBS loan be defeased?
Only if the loan documents provide for it, and only after the lockout period ends. Many fixed-rate conduit loans use defeasance as the main early-exit option. Others use yield maintenance, or let the borrower choose. The prepayment section of the loan agreement settles the question.
Does defeasance pay off the loan?
No. The loan stays outstanding and continues to pay on its original schedule from the securities portfolio. Only the property is released.
How long does it take?
Published guidance from defeasance consultants and servicers puts the process at roughly 30 to 45 days from notice to closing. The longer end applies when a rating agency confirmation is required. The final closing itself takes place in escrow over two to three days.
Publication Assets
Excerpt | Defeasance lets a CMBS borrower release its property before maturity by substituting government securities for the real estate collateral. Learn why CMBS loans can't simply be prepaid, how the replacement collateral works, who is involved, and what it costs. |
Meta description | What is CMBS defeasance? Learn how borrowers replace property collateral with government securities, why CMBS loans restrict prepayment, and what the process costs. |
Primary keyword | CMBS defeasance |
Secondary keywords | what is defeasance, defeasance vs yield maintenance, defeasance lockout, defeasance collateral, commercial real estate defeasance, successor borrower |
Sources
• Treas. Reg. § 1.860G-2(a)(8) (release of REMIC mortgage collateral through defeasance with government securities)



